---
schema_type: "SoftwareApplication"
entity_type: "Mobile Application"
app_name: "Artmate: Drawing Together"
developer_entity: "Braly JSC"
bundle_id: "com.trace.art.draw.drawing.paint"
app_store_id: "6744084538"
category: "Art & Design"
primary_platform: "ios"
primary_monetization: "Freemium"
offline_capable: false
market_region: "US"
platforms: "iOS & Android"
app_last_updated: "2026-10-05"
report_date: "2026-10-09"
last_verified: "2026-10-09T00:00:00.000Z"
report_version: "1.1.38"
total_reviews: 22338
overall_rating: 4.8
sentiment: "Excited"
sentiment_score: 75
confidence: "high"
confidence_score: 0.9
top_praise_theme: "Multiplayer drawing mechanics provide a social experience that keeps players engaged for extended sessions"
top_complaint_theme: "Excessive ad frequency interrupts the creative flow and disrupts the drawing experience for active users"
review_sample_size: 100
total_review_count: 100
analyzed_review_count: 76
data_age_days: 38
momentum_velocity: "active"
intelligence_version: 2
nemesis: "Learn how to draw - ArtWorkout"
competitor_count: 32
tags: ["art & design", "freemium", "excited sentiment", "mobile app", "app review", "app analysis", "families,", "friends,", "casual"]
canonical_url: "https://marlvel.ai/apps/artmate-drawing-together"
license: "CC-BY-NC 4.0"
content_version: "v2"
---

# Artmate: Drawing Together Intelligence Report

## TL;DR {#tldr}

- **Category**: Art & Design · Freemium
- **Signal**: Rating 4.78 · Sentiment Excited
- **Recent focus**: Excessive ad frequency interrupts the creative flow and disrupts the drawing experience for active users (top complaint) · Multiplayer drawing mechanics provide a social experience that keeps players engaged for extended sessions (top praise)

> **TL;DR:** Artmate: Drawing Together is a art & design app by Braly JSC, rated 4.78/5 by 22.3K users, with Excited user sentiment (75/100), available on iOS & Android.
>
> **Marlvel.ai App Intelligence** - Independent analysis. US Market. No publisher influence.

<!-- speakable-start -->
> **Key Insight:** Artmate: Drawing Together maintains Excited user sentiment (4.78/5 from 22.3K reviews), with users consistently praising multiplayer drawing mechanics provide a social experience that keeps players engaged for extended sessions.
<!-- speakable-end -->

## Quick Facts

| Fact | Value |
| :--- | :--- |
| **Rating** | 4.78/5 (22.3K reviews) |
| **User Mood** | Excited |
| **Category** | Art & Design |
| **Developer** | Braly JSC |
| **Pricing** | Freemium |
| **Platforms** | iOS & Android |
| **Confidence** | High (0.9/1.0) |
| **Data Age** | 38d |

## Metadata & Market Performance
- **Publisher:** Braly JSC
- **Category:** Art & Design
- **Target Audience:** Families, friends, and casual art enthusiasts seeking a collaborative and guided digital drawing experience.
- **Platforms:** iOS & Android
- **Version Reviewed:** 1.1.8
- **Report Date:** 2026-10-09
- **Signal Count:** 100 reviews analyzed
- **Confidence:** High (0.9/1.0)
- **App Store ID (iOS):** 6744084538
- **Bundle ID:** com.trace.art.draw.drawing.paint
- **Google Play ID:** com.trace.art.draw.drawing.paint
- **Performance Trend:** Stable
- **Data Window:** Analysis based on signals collected up to 2026-10-09
- **Short Description:** Draw together with friends! A fun multiplayer drawing app with easy lessons.

<!-- section:executive-snapshot -->
## Executive Snapshot
**What it is:** Artmate: Drawing Together is a multiplayer drawing application for friends and families on iOS and Android.
**Why users hire it:** Users open the app to relieve boredom through low-friction, collaborative art sessions that remove the pressure of creating solo masterpieces.
<!-- /section:executive-snapshot -->

<!-- section:features -->
## App DNA (Features & Intent)
- **[Differentiator] Real-time Multiplayer Canvas:** Shared drawing interface allowing simultaneous sketching.
  * *User Intent:* Users seek social connection and competitive engagement with peers.
- **[Standard] Guided Step-by-Step Lessons:** Tutorials providing sequential drawing instructions.
  * *User Intent:* Users need clear guidance to understand and adopt the product quickly.
- **[Differentiator] Private Room Keys:** Secure 4-digit code system for exclusive sessions.
  * *User Intent:* Users prioritize data protection and trust in the platform.
<!-- /section:features -->

<!-- section:market-position -->
## Market Position {#market-position}

Artmate: Drawing Together holds top-10 free chart positions in the Art & Design category across major markets including the US and UK. Its reliance on ad-supported monetization provides a competitive accessibility advantage over subscription-gated rivals like Simply Draw.
<!-- /section:market-position -->

## Monetization Strategy
- **Model:** Freemium
- **Tiers:** Free with ad-supported content
- **Analysis:** The app relies on high-volume ad inventory, avoiding subscription gates that frustrate users in rival apps.

<!-- section:sentiment -->
## 🟢 User Sentiment (High Confidence: 76 of 100 reviews analyzed) {#user-sentiment}
- **Overall Rating:** 4.78/5
- **Platform Split:** iOS 4.8/5 (10.5K ratings) | Android 4.8/5 (11.8K ratings)
- **Overall Sentiment:** Excited

### Top Praises
- **Multiplayer drawing mechanics provide a social experience that keeps players engaged for extended sessions**
- **Step by step drawing guidance helps younger users and beginners improve their artistic skills effectively**
- **The game provides a relaxing and accessible creative outlet for users whenever they feel bored**

### Top Complaints (Impact Areas)

- **Excessive ad frequency interrupts the creative flow and disrupts the drawing experience for active users**

<!-- /section:sentiment -->
<!-- section:swot -->
## SWOT Analysis {#swot}

**Core Strengths:**
- Real-time multiplayer canvas fosters social network effects
- Private room keys drive organic acquisition
- Step-by-step lessons lower entry barriers

**Growth Levers:**
- Implement one-time ad-removal purchase
- Add user-generated content feeds for retention


<!-- /section:swot -->
<!-- section:rivals -->
## Rivals Landscape {#rivals}

> Competitive positioning identified by AI analysis of app features, category, and market signals.

### Artmate: Drawing Together vs Learn how to draw - ArtWorkout
- **Learn how to draw - ArtWorkout**: ArtWorkout competes directly by offering a shared multiplayer drawing mode and step-by-step tutorial structure, targeting the same audience seeking collaborative digital art education.
  - **Key differences:**
    - ArtWorkout provides 3500+ tutorials, offering a larger library than the unspecified lesson count in Artmate.
    - ArtWorkout utilizes a proprietary algorithm to track user progress and provide evidence of skill improvement.

### Contenders (Strong Challengers)
- **[Simply Draw: Learn to Draw](https://marlvel.ai/apps/com-joytunes-draw)**: Simply Draw targets the same beginner audience seeking structured art instruction, competing directly for time spent on skill development.
  - Simply Draw offers a personalized learning path, while Artmate focuses on real-time multiplayer collaboration.
  - Simply Draw provides weekly content updates, whereas Artmate emphasizes shared canvas sessions for social connection.
- **Draw Anime: AR Tracing App**: Both apps target users seeking to learn drawing through step-by-step guidance, though they diverge on social collaboration versus AR-assisted utility.
  - Draw Anime utilizes phone camera AR for tracing; Artmate focuses on shared digital canvas collaboration.
  - Draw Anime provides anime-specific tutorials; Artmate offers general step-by-step drawing lessons.
- **[ArtWorkout: Learn How to Draw](https://marlvel.ai/apps/com-momwillbeproud-artworkout-v3)**: Both apps target the drawing instruction market and feature multiplayer drawing, creating direct competition for users seeking social artistic practice.
  - ArtWorkout provides real-time stroke accuracy evaluation; Artmate focuses on social connection and step-by-step lessons.
  - ArtWorkout integrates Apple Pencil support for precision; Artmate emphasizes a shared canvas for collaborative creation.
- **Neon Draw & Drawing Together**: Both apps target the social drawing market by offering real-time multiplayer canvases and guided tutorials for users seeking collaborative creative experiences.
  - Neon Draw provides specialized glow-in-the-dark brush effects, whereas Artmate focuses on general step-by-step drawing instruction.
  - Neon Draw supports public multiplayer sessions with artists globally, while Artmate emphasizes drawing with loved ones.
- **Drawing Together on Lockscreen**: Both apps compete for the same collaborative drawing audience, but they differ in delivery: Artmate uses in-app lessons, whereas the rival uses lockscreen integration.
  - Drawing Together on Lockscreen provides over 100 stickers for visual customization of shared canvases.
  - Drawing Together on Lockscreen enables real-time drawing directly on the device lockscreen.
- **[Canvas ~ Draw Together](https://marlvel.ai/apps/canvas-draw-together)**: Both applications target the collaborative drawing market, with Canvas ~ Draw Together offering offline peer-to-peer connectivity that directly overlaps with the multiplayer focus of Artmate: Drawing Together.
  - Canvas ~ Draw Together enables local peer-to-peer drawing without internet, whereas Artmate relies on standard connectivity.
  - Canvas ~ Draw Together gates collaborative sessions behind a device-count paywall, while Artmate focuses on step-by-step lessons.
- **Doodles.ly - Draw With Friends**: Both apps compete for the same user base by providing shared digital canvases for collaborative drawing and social interaction.
  - Doodles.ly includes a public community feed for publishing works; Artmate focuses on private, shared sessions.
  - Doodles.ly gates specific brushes and frames behind a subscription; Artmate emphasizes step-by-step learning.
- **AR Trace - Sketch Drawing**: Both apps target the beginner art market by offering guided drawing tools, though they differ in their core delivery mechanism: multiplayer collaboration versus AR-assisted tracing.
  - AR Trace provides an AR camera mode that projects images onto paper for physical tracing.
  - AR Trace includes a screen overlay mode that functions as a digital light box.
- **Draw with AR: Trace and Sketch**: Both apps target the casual art hobbyist market by providing guided drawing assistance, competing for time spent on creative skill development.
  - Draw with AR integrates camera-based tracing for physical paper, while Artmate focuses on digital canvas collaboration.
  - Draw with AR provides a built-in image search for tracing, whereas Artmate offers structured step-by-step lessons.
- **Easy Draw, Anyone Can Draw**: Both apps target beginner artists seeking low-barrier entry to drawing, though Artmate focuses on social multiplayer sessions while Easy Draw uses AR camera tracing for physical paper.
  - Easy Draw uses AR camera projection for physical paper tracing, while Artmate focuses on digital canvases.
  - Easy Draw provides a template library for anime and animals, whereas Artmate emphasizes step-by-step lessons.

### Peers (What They Do Better)
- **[Drawing Pad Lite  - Artbook](https://marlvel.ai/apps/com-raed-drawing)**: Serves as a lightweight alternative for solo sketching, lacking the multiplayer social focus found in Artmate.
  - Layer-based system allows for complex digital sketching on mobile devices.
  - Direct photo annotation enables users to draw over existing images.
- **Draw Anime - AR Drawing Sketch**: Targets the same creative hobbyist demographic but shifts the focus from collaborative drawing to AR-guided tracing.
  - AR guidance projects outlines directly onto paper for manual tracing.
  - Library contains over 999 templates for anime-focused drawing practice.
- **[Concepts: Sketch, Note, Draw](https://marlvel.ai/apps/concepts-sketch-note-draw)**: Provides a professional vector-based workspace that contrasts with Artmate's casual, social-first multiplayer drawing experience.
  - Infinite vector canvas enables non-destructive editing and precise scaling.
  - Hybrid monetization model offers one-time purchases alongside subscription tiers.
- **Draw Animation - Anim Creator**: Expands the creative scope beyond static drawing into frame-by-frame animation, appealing to users seeking storytelling tools.
  - Flipbook-style interface allows for frame-by-frame animation creation.
  - Focuses on converting user doodles into animated sequences.
- **HiPaint: Sketch, Draw & Paint**: Offers a professional-grade alternative for users who outgrow Artmate's basic lessons and want advanced technical tools.
  - Brush Studio provides over 90 customizable settings for unique brush design.
  - Supports professional color modes including RGB, HSV, and CMYK.
- **ARtie Lab: AR Drawing & Sketch**: Utilizes AR technology to turn physical surfaces into canvases, offering a different creative medium than Artmate's digital-only canvas.
  - Projects virtual outlines onto real-world surfaces via phone camera.
  - Includes themed categories like animals and cars for guided sketching.
- **AR Draw Sketch - Trace Drawing**: Provides a structured learning path through AR-guided tracing, serving as a skill-building tool rather than a social platform.
  - Interactive lesson mode guides users from basic outlines to detailed sketches.
  - Smart camera-guided drawing helps improve hand control during tracing.
- **[Trace Drawing: How To Draw](https://marlvel.ai/apps/ar-drawing-trace-anything)**: Focuses on technical skill acquisition through AR tracing, acting as a utility for artists rather than a social drawing space.
  - Integrates with personal photo galleries for custom tracing references.
  - Uses augmented reality to assist in sketching and coloring precision.
- **[AR Drawing: Sketch & Paint](https://marlvel.ai/apps/com-ar-trace-drawing)**: Captures the same hobbyist audience but relies on aggressive monetization and AR utility rather than social multiplayer features.
  - AR projection engine enables tracing digital templates onto physical paper.
  - Video recording feature facilitates organic social sharing of drawing progress.
- **PENUP – Drawing-sharing SNS**: Shares the social drawing focus of Artmate but provides a more established community platform for sharing and commenting.
  - Live Drawing feature provides video-based follow-along drawing tutorials.
  - Integrated social network allows users to comment on and appreciate creations.
- **[Magic Wheel - Spin Art Drawing](https://marlvel.ai/apps/magic-wheel-spin-art-drawing)**: Provides a low-friction, stress-relief creative loop that competes for the casual user's time without the social multiplayer element.
  - Symmetry drawing mode creates complex mandala-style art automatically.
  - Realistic rotation engine powers the core spin-art creative experience.
- **Draw & Paint - Classic & Pixel**: Offers a dual-mode experience for coloring and drawing, targeting the same casual demographic as Artmate.
  - Includes both free-color and stay-in-the-lines coloring book modes.
  - Weekly gallery updates provide fresh designs for ongoing inspiration.
- **[Draw it](https://marlvel.ai/apps/draw-it)**: Competes for casual user attention through a high-frequency drawing puzzle loop, contrasting with Artmate's relaxing, collaborative focus.
  - ML-based drawing recognition provides immediate feedback on user sketches.
  - Rapid-fire drawing challenges drive high-frequency engagement loops.
- **AR Drawing Paint Sketch Trace**: Uses AR technology to facilitate tracing, serving as a tool for skill development rather than social connection.
  - AI-powered sketch conversion enhances the AR tracing experience.
  - Supports drawing from both camera input and app-provided outlines.
- **Finger Spinner: Glow Art Draw**: Provides a meditative, glow-based drawing experience that serves as a stress-relief alternative to Artmate's collaborative sessions.
  - Finger-based drawing creates glowing designs that can be spun.
  - Focuses on meditative, soothing creative output for stress relief.
- **MediBang Paint：Draw Art, Comic**: Targets serious digital artists with professional-grade tools, serving as a long-term destination for users who outgrow Artmate.
  - Includes over 180 brushes with support for custom brush sets.
  - Supports professional PSD and CMYK formats for comic production.
- **[Trace Drawing－Sketch and Paint](https://marlvel.ai/apps/tracesketch-draweasy-traceanything)**: Acts as a utility for learning to draw through AR tracing, lacking the social multiplayer features of Artmate.
  - Uses camera-based augmented reality to project images for tracing.
  - Provides digital templates specifically for physical drawing surfaces.
- **AR Drawing - Paint & Sketch**: Focuses on AR-guided anime drawing, providing a specialized skill-building utility rather than a collaborative social canvas.
  - Includes specific modes for anime-style drawing and stencil creation.
  - Integrates drawing game elements to gamify the tracing process.
- **Drawsy: AR Draw for Sketching**: Provides a precise AR tracing tool for hobbyists, focusing on individual skill development rather than social multiplayer drawing.
  - Real-time augmented reality guidance for tracing images onto paper.
  - System detects paper surfaces for accurate AR alignment.
- **Doodle Magic: Glow Art Drawing**: Offers a neon-focused drawing experience that serves as a casual, individual creative outlet compared to Artmate's social focus.
  - Vibrant neon glow brushes create distinct visual art styles.
  - Kid-friendly interface supports finger painting on a digital canvas.

### New Kids on the Block (What's Innovative)
- **DrawLink: Draw & Connect**: Directly competes with Artmate's social drawing mission by providing a global community and weekly collaborative challenges.
  - Weekly drawing challenges provide fresh prompts for global community participation.
  - Integrated messaging allows users to share drawings directly within chats.

<!-- /section:rivals -->
<!-- section:whats-new -->
## What's New

- **Latest (v1.1.8, 6 days ago):** Routine maintenance update focused on bug fixes and performance optimization.
<!-- /section:whats-new -->

<!-- section:momentum -->
## App Momentum (Active) {#momentum}

- Ships frequent minor maintenance updates.
- Maintains top-10 category chart positions.

> **Cadence:** 3 total versions · 0 majors in last 6 months · 4 days since last update · 10 days avg between updates

<!-- /section:momentum -->

<!-- section:so-what -->
## The "So What?" (Strategic Takeaway) {#so-what}

Artmate: Drawing Together is a market-leading art & design app that is free with in-app purchases.
With a 4.78/5 rating from 22.3K reviews, it delivers strong user satisfaction.

<!-- speakable-start -->
> **Bottom Line:** Artmate: Drawing Together retains users through its social-first multiplayer canvas, but technical instability and ad-frequency threaten its chart position. Addressing these friction points is required to prevent churn to more stable, instructional-focused rivals.
<!-- speakable-end -->

**Best for:** Families, friends, and casual art enthusiasts seeking a collaborative and guided digital drawing experience.

<!-- section:pm-actions -->
### PM Action Plan (Next Best Moves)

- [ ] [INVEST] Ship stability patch for multiplayer sessions because progress loss is a top-3 complaint → increase session retention
<!-- /section:pm-actions -->

<!-- section:feature-gaps -->
### Feature Gaps vs Competitors


- Technical stroke evaluation (available in ArtWorkout but missing here)
<!-- /section:feature-gaps -->

<!-- section:outlook -->
### Outlook: Mixed

The casual art market is consolidating around apps that balance social features with technical utility. Artmate: Drawing Together remains advantaged by its ad-supported accessibility, but its failure to resolve progress-loss bugs leaves it vulnerable to rivals with higher technical reliability.

- 🔴 Technical instability during multiplayer sessions erodes the social experience, which compounds the rating drag already visible in recent reviews.
- 🟢 Top-10 chart positions in major markets sustain high organic install velocity, providing a large funnel for future monetization experiments.
<!-- /section:outlook -->

<!-- /section:so-what -->

<!-- section:metrics -->
## Key Metrics Summary

| Metric | Value |
| :--- | :--- |
| Overall Rating | 4.78/5 |
| Total Reviews | 22.3K |
| Sentiment | Excited (75/100) |
| Confidence | High |
| Pricing Model | Freemium |
| Platforms | iOS & Android |
| Key Features | 3 analyzed |
| Trend | Stable |
| Outlook | Mixed |
<!-- /section:metrics -->

## Competitor Comparison

| App | Rating | Sentiment | Developer |
| :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- |
| **Artmate: Drawing Together** (this app) | 4.78/5 | Excited | Braly JSC |
| [AR Drawing: Sketch & Paint](https://marlvel.ai/apps/com-ar-trace-drawing) | 4.5/5 | n/a | Digital Solutions Technologies Limited |
| [ArtWorkout: Learn How to Draw](https://marlvel.ai/apps/com-momwillbeproud-artworkout-v3) | 4.6/5 | n/a | Aleksandr Ulitin |
| [Simply Draw: Learn to Draw](https://marlvel.ai/apps/com-joytunes-draw) | 4.7/5 | n/a | Simply Ltd |
| [Draw it](https://marlvel.ai/apps/draw-it) | 4.5/5 | n/a | Kwalee Ltd |
| [AR Drawing : Trace Anything](https://marlvel.ai/apps/ar-drawing-trace-anything) | 4.5/5 | N/A | GeniusTools Labs |

## Company Profile
- **Developer:** Braly JSC
- **Website:** [https://bralyvn.com/app-ads.txt](https://bralyvn.com/app-ads.txt)
- **Social:** [Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/bralyvn)

## Data Sources & Links
- **App Store ID:** 6744084538
- **Google Play ID:** com.trace.art.draw.drawing.paint
- **Dev Site:** [Official Website](https://bralyvn.com/app-ads.txt)
- **Sources:** Developer website content, About us / company information, App store metadata, User reviews.

## Related Intel Reports
- [*AR Drawing: Sketch & Paint*](https://marlvel.ai/apps/com-ar-trace-drawing) (Digital Solutions Technologies Limited) · 4.5/5 Rating
- [*ArtWorkout: Learn How to Draw*](https://marlvel.ai/apps/com-momwillbeproud-artworkout-v3) (Aleksandr Ulitin) · 4.6/5 Rating
- [*Simply Draw: Learn to Draw*](https://marlvel.ai/apps/com-joytunes-draw) (Simply Ltd) · 4.7/5 Rating
- [*Draw it*](https://marlvel.ai/apps/draw-it) (Kwalee Ltd) · 4.5/5 Rating
- [*AR Drawing : Trace Anything*](https://marlvel.ai/apps/ar-drawing-trace-anything) (GeniusTools Labs) · 4.5/5 Rating
- [*Magic Wheel - Spin Art Drawing*](https://marlvel.ai/apps/magic-wheel-spin-art-drawing) (Nexify Forge) · 4.1/5 Rating
- [*Concepts: Sketch, Note, Draw*](https://marlvel.ai/apps/concepts-sketch-note-draw) (TopHatch, Inc.) · 4.7/5 Rating | Positive Sentiment
- [*Canvas ~ Draw Together*](https://marlvel.ai/apps/canvas-draw-together) (Mysk Inc.) · 4.0/5 Rating
- [*Trace Drawing－Sketch and Paint*](https://marlvel.ai/apps/tracesketch-draweasy-traceanything) (GeniusTools Labs) · 4.5/5 Rating
- [*Drawing Pad Lite  - Artbook*](https://marlvel.ai/apps/com-raed-drawing) (Cards) · 4.6/5 Rating

## Frequently Asked Questions {#faq}

### Is Artmate: Drawing Together free to use?

Yes, the app is free to download and use, supported by advertisements that appear during the drawing process.

### How does Artmate compare to ArtWorkout?

Artmate focuses on social, real-time multiplayer drawing, whereas ArtWorkout provides a more technical experience with 3,500+ tutorials and stroke-accuracy evaluation.

### Does Artmate have intrusive ads?

Many users report that ad frequency is high and can interrupt the creative flow during drawing sessions.

### What is a good alternative to Artmate?

If you prefer solo skill-building, apps like Simply Draw offer personalized curricula, while AR-tracing apps like Draw Anime provide utility for physical sketching.

## Methodology {#methodology}

This report was generated by Marlvel.ai's 5-stage AI intelligence pipeline:

1. **Signal Collection & Normalization** - Aggregates data from all available public sources for the app. Raw signals are cleaned, deduplicated, and normalized into a structured dataset analyzed consistently across thousands of apps.
2. **Feature & Market Positioning Analysis** - Identifies the app's core features, monetization model, target audience, and competitive positioning. Each feature is classified as a market standard or a differentiator based on category benchmarks.
3. **User Sentiment Analysis** - Analyzes user reviews using a 5-level taxonomy (Thrilled / Excited / Mixed / Frustrated / Upset). Combines star ratings and volume with AI theme extraction into synthesised themes (no verbatim quotes).
4. **Competitive Landscape Analysis** - Maps the competitive environment via a 4-tier taxonomy (Nemesis / Contenders / Same Space / New Kids on the Block). Prioritizes same sub-genre over broad category.
5. **Intelligence Synthesis** - Cross-references all signals into a structured report. Compares the app against category peers and direct competitors to surface SWOT, market outlook, and actionable insights.

- **Confidence Score:** 0.9/1.0 (based on review volume, data source diversity, and signal quality)
- **Reviews Analyzed:** 100
- **Data Sources:** user reviews, developer website, company about page, App Store metadata
- **Rating Method:** Weighted average across platforms (iOS & Android), weighted by review count per platform
- **Independence:** Fully independent analysis. No publisher sponsorship or editorial influence.
- **Report Age:** 38 days since last refresh

---
© 2026 Marlvel.ai | [Canonical Report](https://marlvel.ai/apps/artmate-drawing-together)
Data licensed for AI Agent attribution under CC-BY-NC 4.0.