Isle of Skye vs its rivals

Side-by-side comparison against Isle of Skye's closest competitors — identity, store metrics, ratings & sentiment, and strategic intel.

Isle of Skye
This App
Everdell
New Kid
Core Identity
DeveloperAaron TaylorMeeple CorpMarmalade Game StudioDire Wolf DigitalMonster CouchDIGIDICEDDire Wolf Digital
CategoryGamesGamesGamesGamesGamesGamesGames
PlatformAndroid, iOSiOS, AndroidAndroid, iOSAndroid, iOSAndroid, iOSiOS, AndroidAndroid, iOS
Store Metrics
Rating2.9 / 54.9 / 54.6 / 54.9 / 54.8 / 53.5 / 54.8 / 5
Ratings Count5916410,4694,89212,4501402,453
PriceUSD3.99$3.99$4.99$4.99$9.99$8.99$4.99
Release DateAug 6, 2018Jun 26, 2025Dec 12, 2023Sep 24, 2020Jul 20, 2021Mar 3, 2019Jul 28, 2022
Last UpdatedMay 19, 2026Apr 17, 2026May 13, 2026Mar 11, 2026Jan 29, 2026Jan 26, 2026May 19, 2026
Sentiment & Reviews
Sentimentterriblepositiveterriblepositive-mixedmixed
Score15/10075/10015/10075/100-45/10055/100
Praises
  • Strategic depth and variety of tiles provide high replayability for board game enthusiasts
  • Faithful digital adaptation of the physical board game mechanics provides an authentic tabletop experience
  • Core strategy gameplay loop remains highly engaging for long-term fans of the board game
  • Cross-platform account synchronization allows players to transition between mobile and desktop play sessions seamlessly
-
  • Faithful digital adaptation of the tabletop classic provides deep strategic gameplay for enthusiasts
  • Faithful digital adaptation of the board game mechanics provides an accessible experience for tabletop fans
  • High quality art and sound design create an immersive atmosphere for long-term board game enthusiasts
Complaints
  • Persistent black screen on launch prevents access to the game for many users
  • Three-dimensional board view and camera controls obscure gameplay and complicate precise tile placement during matches
  • Frequent application crashes during online matches render the game effectively unplayable for most users
  • Lack of a competitive ranking system leads to frequent player abandonment during online matches
-
  • Frequent application crashes and freezing during matches disrupt the flow of gameplay sessions
  • Lack of an undo button leads to accidental moves and wasted turns during gameplay sessions
  • Unstable server connections cause players to be kicked from active multiplayer games without recourse
Requests
  • Implementation of a speed-up option for coin distribution and point tallying
  • Accessibility features including colorblind modes are required to distinguish between similar colored tile types
  • Refunds or tangible compensation requested for paid content that is currently inaccessible
  • Implementation of a competitive Elo-based ranking system to discourage match abandonment
-
  • Implementation of a turbo mode or animation toggle to accelerate the pace of play
  • Expansion content availability is requested to increase replayability and depth for veteran board game players
Strategic Intel
Strengths
  • Award-winning board game mechanics provide high tactical replayability [2016 Kennerspiel des Jahres Winner]
  • Asynchronous multiplayer loop enables long-term engagement [Asynchronous Multiplayer feature]
  • Faithful adaptation of Spiel des Jahres mechanics sustains high user satisfaction
  • Cross-platform account linking increases multi-device stickiness
  • Asynchronous play enables long-term engagement loops [Retention Metric]
  • Companion app integration drives social virality [Acquisition Lever]
  • Faithful mechanical adaptation of physical board game rules
  • Cross-platform account synchronization across mobile and desktop
  • Immersive woodland art and sound design
-
  • Faithful digital adaptation of the tabletop classic
  • Cross-platform infrastructure for multiplayer
  • GLICKO-based competitive ladder
  • Faithful tabletop adaptation sustains organic interest
  • High-fidelity art assets drive immersion
  • Cross-platform multiplayer expands potential player base
Weaknesses
  • Persistent black screen launch failure [User Sentiment]
  • Unresponsive customer support for technical issues [User Sentiment]
  • Mid-game freezes during tile placement [User Sentiment]
  • 3D camera controls obscure legal placement spots
  • Monetization relies on aesthetic items rather than high-value content expansions
  • Frequent online crashes during matches [Stability Metric]
  • Aggressive monetization of inaccessible content [Sentiment Trend]
  • Lack of competitive ranking system for online play
  • High cumulative cost of expansion content
  • Inconsistent AI behavior in solo sessions
-
  • Frequent application crashes and freezing
  • Lack of speed controls for animations
  • Aggressive DLC gating for existing owners
  • Server instability causes match drops
  • UI scaling issues on mobile devices
  • Premium price point above casual-game median
Pricingpaidpaidpaidpaidpaidpaidpaid
MomentumMaintenanceActiveMaintenanceMaintenanceActiveMaintenanceActive
Update Cadence5 versions, 3 majors/6mo, ~205d avg5 versions, 4 majors/6mo, ~11d avg5 versions, 2 majors/6mo, ~37d avg5 versions, ~22d avg5 versions5 versions, 2 majors/6mo, ~207d avg5 versions, 4 majors/6mo, ~22d avg

Compare Isle of Skye head-to-head

Disclosure: Independent intel to help mobile builders succeed.

AI-powered analysis with editorial review, built from publicly available sources. Marlvel.ai is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Isle of Skye, its developer, the app publisher, Apple, or Google Play. All trademarks, logos, and screenshots referenced remain the property of their respective owners.

Data licensed under CC-BY-NC 4.0