Herd
By Herd Music
Herd is a music curation app for iOS and Android that allows users to rank songs and write reviews.
The App DNA
What makes this app unique?
Users hire Herd to build a personal, intentional archive of music memories that streaming algorithms ignore.
For Music enthusiasts who prioritize manual curation and social sharing over algorithmic recommendations.
Key features
Binary comparison of songs to generate ranked lists of favorites
Import and export playlists between Herd and external streaming services
Manual discovery of tracks via community and friend activity rather than automated algorithms
Text-based reviews for lyrics, memories, and thoughts attached to specific songs
How much does it cost?
The app currently operates as a free, ad-free utility without visible monetization gates or subscription tiers.
Velocity
Maintenance developmentnew contentsocial featuresShow more...
The app currently ships at a maintenance-level cadence of approximately 0.08 releases per week. While the latest release was a major update introducing discovery and social features, the significant time gap between the iOS and Android releases suggests a lack of consistent, cross-platform development momentum. The development trend is currently stable but infrequent, focusing on feature-heavy updates rather than iterative improvements. There is no evidence of a live-ops strategy or high-frequency deployment cycle.
Who built it?
User Sentiment
What do users think recently?
Fresh user feedback skews thrilled. Users appreciate social discovery features allow users to track friend listening habits and find new music and intentional music exploration design encourages deep listening rather than passive algorithmic consumption.
How are ratings & reviews evolving?
What users say, by theme
- Social discovery features allow users to track friend listening habits and find new music
- Intentional music exploration design encourages deep listening rather than passive algorithmic consumption
- Gamified ranking mechanics make the process of reviewing and sharing music highly enjoyable
- Scrolling limitations on specific screens prevent users from completing long-form music reviews
11 of 11 recent reviews analyzed · moderate confidence · Thrilled overall
Read the full review analysisCompetition
Competitive landscape for Herd
How's the Music market?
Herd operates as a niche music utility, maintaining a 4.8 rating on iOS. The lack of Android traction compared to the iOS release indicates a significant distribution gap in the music-tracking segment.
Read the market outlookThe rivals identified
By Mike Clay
Dominates the music tracking niche with massive user-generated data and deep integration with Apple Music listening history.
- Provides deep, automated analytical insights into listening habits that Herd’s manual rating system cannot replicate.
- Leverages direct Apple Music API integration to track every play without requiring manual user input.
Unlock the deeper market read.
Access the full report for freeThe Analyst's Read
Key takeaways for Herd
Where is it heading?
The music-tracking market is consolidating around automated data-viz tools, leaving manual-curation apps like Herd exposed to churn from users who prefer passive insights. Herd must bridge the gap between manual intentionality and automated convenience to maintain its position against high-velocity competitors.
- The persistent scrolling bug on review screens blocks user content creation, which directly limits the growth of the app's unique review database.
- The recent addition of playlist import functionality lowers the barrier to entry, which should improve new-user retention by reducing the time to first value.
The SWOT
- Social discovery features tie engagement to peer interaction
- Manual curation creates unique user-generated content that increases switching costs
- Integration of concert data bridges the gap between song rating and live engagement
- B2B partnerships with independent labels for artist-led curation
Next best moves
Fix scrolling bug on review screens because user complaints block content submission → increase review completion rate
+ 1 more prioritized moveThe counter-intuitive read
Herd's manual-input model is not a weakness but…
Read the full takeFeature gaps
Automated listening history tracking (available in PlayTally but missing here) +1
Since the last report: The report identifies a new critical scrolling bug impacting review completion and a shift in the contrarian perspective regarding the app's manual-input model.
Bottom line
Herd builds strong retention through intentional curation, but the manual-input barrier limits its scale against automated rivals, so the PM should prioritize automation of library imports to reduce user friction.
Unlock 2 critical frictions, 2 market threats, 1 more prioritized move and the analyst’s take.
Access the full report for freeReport last updated