Small Craft Advisor vs its rivals

Side-by-side comparison against Small Craft Advisor's closest competitors — identity, store metrics, ratings & sentiment, and strategic intel.

Yacht-ID
New Kid
Core Identity
DeveloperMagzter Inc.SkipperiActive Interest Media, IncHaymarketHothouse PublishingBlumoon
CategoryLifestyleLifestyleLifestyleLifestyleLifestyleAuto & Vehicles
PlatformiOS, AndroidiOS, AndroidiOSiOS, AndroidiOS, AndroidAndroid
Store Metrics
Rating2.3 / 50.0 / 54.7 / 54.8 / 54.8 / 50.0 / 5
Ratings Count6068712110
PriceFreeFreeFreeFreeFree$0.99
Release DateNov 17, 2014Jun 11, 2020Dec 11, 2013Mar 1, 2012Nov 22, 2011Apr 28, 2026
Last UpdatedAug 2, 2018Apr 21, 2026Jan 23, 2026Feb 6, 2026Nov 10, 2025May 7, 2026
Sentiment & Reviews
Sentimentmixedmixedterribleterribleterrible-
Score46/10045/10015/10015/10020/100-
Praises-
  • The boat reservation service provides a convenient way to explore new locations during the summer season
  • Check-in and check-out processes are quick and simple for active subscribers using the mobile application
  • The core magazine content provides high value for readers when the app functions correctly
  • High quality journalism and photography content keeps long-term readers engaged with the publication
  • Timeless editorial content provides escapism and high quality imagery for classic car enthusiasts
-
Complaints-
  • The application reloads mid-process if the screen goes dark, forcing users to restart their check-in
  • Subscription and reservation logic fails to provide transparency or functionality after the user logs into the account
  • Availability of boats is frequently reported as fully booked, contradicting the advertised service accessibility
  • Subscription authentication failures prevent users from accessing paid digital content across multiple devices
  • New issue delivery is frequently delayed or missing entirely from the digital library
  • Lack of responsive customer support leaves users without recourse for subscription or access issues
  • Persistent server connection failures prevent users from accessing purchased digital magazine issues
  • Previous digital purchases and historical issues disappear following major application updates and migrations
-
Requests-
  • Users request visibility into boat availability times to see when the previous customer reservation ends
  • Integration for existing web-based digital subscribers to access content within the mobile application
-
  • Implementation of text scaling and zoom controls to improve readability on mobile devices
-
Strategic Intel
Strengths
  • Plan study library functions as a high-switching-cost barrier for DIY boat builders
  • Subscription-based fleet access model lowers entry barrier for non-owners
  • Geofencing navigation integration protects fleet asset value and reduces insurance liability
  • Skipperi Academy certification lowers training friction for new recreational boaters
  • Century-long brand authority sustains category leadership
  • High-value editorial content provides unique utility
  • Editorial authority built on decades of print heritage
  • Comprehensive global events calendar functions as a unique utility
  • Authoritative celebrity editorial content sustains high-intent enthusiast engagement
  • Integrated classic car marketplace creates a unique utility beyond static reading
-
Weaknesses
  • 2.33-star rating on iOS signals significant interface friction
  • No cross-platform account synchronization
  • App state-loss during screen timeouts forces check-in restarts
  • Reservation button visibility issues post-login drive user frustration
  • Boat availability gaps contradict advertised service accessibility
  • Subscription authentication failures block paid access
  • 0-star support responsiveness exacerbates churn
  • Digital delivery delays compared to print
  • Persistent server connection failures blocking paid content
  • Unresponsive support channels and broken password reset links
  • Basic PDF-style reader degrades high-resolution photography
  • Recurring content-access failure post-update triggers high churn
  • Unresponsive support fails to resolve payment verification issues
  • Fixed-layout scaling prevents comfortable tablet reading
-
Pricingsubscriptionsubscriptionsubscriptionsubscriptionsubscriptionpaid
MomentumZombieMaintenanceMaintenanceMaintenanceMaintenance-
Update Cadence2 versions, 1 majors/6mo, ~2601d avg2 versions, ~5d avg1 versions2 versions, ~74d avg2 versions, 1 majors/6mo, ~5d avg-

Compare Small Craft Advisor head-to-head

Disclosure: Independent intel to help mobile builders succeed.

AI-powered analysis with editorial review, built from publicly available sources. Marlvel.ai is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Small Craft Advisor, its developer, the app publisher, Apple, or Google Play. All trademarks, logos, and screenshots referenced remain the property of their respective owners.

Data licensed under CC-BY-NC 4.0