The Secret Society: Mystery vs its rivals

Side-by-side comparison against The Secret Society: Mystery's closest competitors — identity, store metrics, ratings & sentiment, and strategic intel.

	The Secret Society: Mystery This App	June's Journey: Hidden Objects Nemesis	Mystery Manor: hidden objects Contender	Manor Matters®: Adventure Game Contender	Seekers Notes: Hidden Objects Contender	Clockmaker: Match 3 Puzzles Peer	Adventure Escape Mysteries Peer	Pearl's Peril - Hidden Objects Peer	Rooms & Exits: Puzzle escape New Kid
Core Identity
Developer	G5 Entertainment AB	wooga	Game Insight	Playrix	Mytona	Samfinaco LLC	Haiku Games Co	wooga	WEBELINX GAMES DOO
Category	Games	Games	Games	-	Games	Games	Games	Games	Games
Platform	Android, iOS	iOS, Android	iOS, Android	-	Android, iOS	iOS, Android	iOS, Android	iOS, Android	iOS
Store Metrics
Rating	4.3 / 5	4.6 / 5	4.5 / 5	-	4.3 / 5	4.6 / 5	4.8 / 5	4.6 / 5	4.7 / 5
Ratings Count	41,757	323,988	30,100	-	94,786	183,371	19,893	40,123	13,657
Price	Free	Free	Free	-	Free	Free	Free	Free	Free
Release Date	Nov 21, 2012	Dec 23, 2021	Jun 8, 2018	-	Jul 30, 2015	Feb 5, 2015	Dec 21, 2018	May 6, 2015	Jan 28, 2021
Last Updated	Apr 22, 2026	Apr 15, 2026	Apr 22, 2026	-	Apr 3, 2026	Apr 29, 2026	Apr 15, 2026	Mar 2, 2026	Apr 2, 2026
Sentiment & Reviews
Sentiment	mixed	negative	negative	-	mixed	mixed	-	mixed	-
Score	65/100	32/100	35/100	-	45/100	75/100	-	55/100	-
Praises	Long-term engagement through diverse hidden object puzzles and collection tasks	Engaging Narrative Relaxing Experience	Engaging mystery narrative and hidden object gameplay provide a relaxing mental escape for long-term players	-	Engaging Gameplay High-Quality Graphics	Diverse puzzle variety within the core gameplay loop keeps sessions engaging and prevents boredom	-	Engaging Gameplay Relaxing Experience	-
Complaints	Aggressive monetization and difficulty spikes force players into spending real money	Aggressive Monetization Technical Instability	Excessive ad length and frequency post-update disrupt the flow of gameplay and frustrate active users	-	Excessive Ads Technical Bugs and Crashes Loss of Progress	Excessive ad frequency and unskippable promotional content disrupt the flow of gameplay sessions	-	Technical Stability and Crashes Account and Progress Loss Excessive Advertising	-
Requests	Improved inventory management for gifting and opening multiple tool chests	-	Implementation of a paid ad-free upgrade option to improve the user experience for dedicated players	-	-	-	-	-	-
Strategic Intel
Strengths	11-language localization library functions as a B2B distribution barrier Persistent collection-based loop sustains long-term daily engagement	Strong 1920s thematic consistency Weekly episodic content updates Deep social integration via Detective Clubs	Offline-play capability functions as a distribution moat for travel-based usage Hand-drawn art style sustains a distinct detective-novel atmosphere	-	10-year content library and established lore Unique multi-genre puzzle integration (Match-3 + HO) Strong social 'Guild' infrastructure	Victorian-mystery narrative creates a distinct atmospheric hook Offline-play capability sustains DAU during travel 52-building restoration loop provides long-term progression	-	Superior island customization (Artemis Island) compared to static-map rivals Cohesive 1930s 'Golden Age' aesthetic and high-quality hand-drawn art Strong long-term retention among veteran players (multi-year tenure)	-
Weaknesses	0.17 rating gap between Android and iOS platforms Persistent content-download errors blocking gameplay Aggressive monetization spikes in the latest update	Frequent ad-related crashes Perceived pay-to-win progression balance Unresponsive customer support	0.07★ Android-iOS rating gap indicates platform-specific instability Ad-length complaints (2+ minutes) drive negative sentiment	-	Critical technical bugs causing progress loss Aggressive ad frequency (30s ads per 90s play) App crashes and loading screen failures in recent versions	High ad-frequency drives uninstall intent Technical ad-playback failures cause progress loss Aggressive monetization pop-ups trigger churn	-	Frequent technical crashes and freezes in recent versions (v9.11.x) Unreliable account sync/save-game features leading to progress loss Aggressive ad strategy with reports of 90-second unskippable ads	-
Pricing	freemium	freemium	freemium	-	freemium	freemium	freemium	freemium	freemium
Momentum	Active	Active	Active	-	Active	Active	Active	Maintenance	Intense
Update Cadence	5 versions, 2 majors/6mo, ~9d avg	3 versions, 1 majors/6mo, ~12d avg	5 versions, 5 majors/6mo, ~14d avg	-	2 versions, 2 majors/6mo, ~0d avg	5 versions, 4 majors/6mo, ~7d avg	5 versions	2 versions, ~6d avg	5 versions

Compare The Secret Society: Mystery head-to-head