Old Navy: Shop for New Clothes vs its rivals

Side-by-side comparison against Old Navy: Shop for New Clothes's closest competitors — identity, store metrics, ratings & sentiment, and strategic intel.

H&M
Contender
AE + Aerie
Contender
Core Identity
DeveloperGap Inc.TargetH&MAmerican Eagle OutfittersMacys IncNike, IncNordstrom, Inc.Vinted Limited
CategoryShoppingShoppingShoppingShoppingShoppingShoppingShoppingShopping
PlatformiOSAndroid, iOSAndroid, iOSiOS, AndroidiOSAndroid, iOSiOS, AndroidAndroid, iOS
Store Metrics
Rating4.9 / 54.9 / 54.8 / 54.9 / 54.9 / 54.9 / 54.9 / 54.8 / 5
Ratings Count1,375,0386,700,077225,1911,182,3112,264,1961,699,1401,416,99152,987
PriceFreeFreeFreeFreeFreeFreeFreeFree
Release DateDec 11, 2009Nov 25, 2008Jul 7, 2018Oct 6, 2011Dec 14, 2009Aug 2, 2016Nov 15, 2011Apr 11, 2013
Last UpdatedApr 23, 2026May 12, 2026Apr 30, 2026Apr 23, 2026Apr 16, 2026Apr 29, 2026Apr 20, 2026Apr 13, 2026
Sentiment & Reviews
Sentimentpositivemixedmixedpositivepositivemixedpositivepositive
Score75/10055/10055/10078/10062/10045/10082/10072/100
Praises
  • Broad product selection and consistent sizing options drive high customer satisfaction across diverse family needs
  • Convenient curbside pickup and delivery services save time for busy families and multitaskers
  • Wide variety of clothing options and high quality materials keep long-term customers satisfied with their purchases
  • Extensive product selection and sizing options drive high satisfaction for diverse body types
  • User-Friendly Navigation
  • Competitive Pricing and Deals
  • Fast shipping and delivery times keep customers satisfied with their online shopping experience
  • Exceptional customer service interactions build long-term trust and brand loyalty for shoppers
  • Ease of Use
  • Value and Pricing
Complaints
  • Technical instability including application crashes and loading failures prevents users from completing purchase transactions
  • Inaccurate online inventory and stock status lead to order cancellations and customer frustration
  • Navigation regressions post-update cause the search results to reset to the top when returning from items
  • Post-update login and authentication loops prevent users from accessing their accounts
  • App Stability and Crashes
  • Order Fulfillment and Cancellations
  • Automated bot activity during limited product drops prevents genuine customers from securing purchases
  • Technical regressions post-update prevent product selection and cart functionality for mobile users
  • Customer Support Quality
  • Automated Moderation and Bans
Requests
  • Integrated account management features for store credit cards to avoid external banking application reliance
  • Enhanced filtering options to exclude online-only items from in-store pickup search results
  • Improved inventory transparency and stock notifications for specific sizes to prevent wasted search time
  • Advanced review filtering by height and weight to improve sizing accuracy
-
  • Dark mode interface requested to improve visual comfort during late-night browsing sessions
  • Expanded inventory of trendier and edgier fashion styles to supplement classic offerings
-
Strategic Intel
Strengths
  • Integrated loyalty dashboard gamifies repeat purchase frequency
  • Proprietary credit card integration increases switching costs
  • Broad family-focused catalog sustains high organic install velocity
  • Proprietary Drive Up service creates a physical-digital fulfillment barrier
  • Circle loyalty program integrates payment and savings into a single barcode
  • AR-based virtual try-on reduces return rates in high-margin beauty
  • Loyalty program gamification drives repeat purchase frequency
  • Scan & Find feature bridges physical-digital inventory gaps
  • Real Rewards program creates high-switching-cost retention loop
  • Omnichannel inventory visibility drives physical store foot traffic
  • Massive user base (2.2M+ ratings)
  • Exclusive high-end brand partnerships (Nike, lululemon)
  • Integrated Macy's Pay for seamless rewards application
  • Exclusive access to Jordan-brand inventory
  • Deep integration of Nike Member rewards
  • High-fidelity in-store barcode scanning tools
  • High-touch service model builds long-term customer trust
  • O2O integration via curbside pickup bridges physical retail
  • Loyalty program gamification drives repeat purchase frequency
  • Zero seller fees model
  • High inventory volume
  • Intuitive listing and shipping UX
Weaknesses
  • Persistent app crashes during checkout
  • Lack of in-app credit card management
  • Inconsistent pricing display during Apple Pay transactions
  • Inaccurate inventory data leads to frequent order cancellations
  • Complex payment flows block transactions
  • Search results lack relevance for specific item discovery
  • Navigation regressions in the latest version force search restarts
  • Inconsistent return and refund processing damages customer trust
  • Recurring authentication loops post-update
  • Inconsistent reward application at checkout
  • Lack of granular review filtering by body type
  • Critical 'filter crash' bug in search
  • High frequency of order cancellations/verification issues
  • Maintenance-only update cycle (v2604.2.0)
  • Bot-driven inventory depletion during drops
  • Frequent login loops and app crashes
  • Inaccurate local store inventory filtering
  • Technical regressions in the latest update break cart functionality
  • Removal of product composition data increases return risk
  • Inconsistent in-store service quality across regions
  • Poor human customer support
  • Aggressive automated moderation/bans
  • Lack of authentication for luxury goods
Pricingfreefreemiumfreefreefreefreefreefreemium
MomentumActiveActiveActiveActiveMaintenanceActiveActiveMaintenance
Update Cadence5 versions, ~10d avg5 versions, ~9d avg5 versions, ~9d avg5 versions, ~5d avg5 versions, ~11d avg5 versions, ~5d avg5 versions, ~4d avg4 versions, ~14d avg

Compare Old Navy: Shop for New Clothes head-to-head

Disclosure: Independent intel to help mobile builders succeed.

AI-powered analysis with editorial review, built from publicly available sources. Marlvel.ai is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Old Navy: Shop for New Clothes, its developer, the app publisher, Apple, or Google Play. All trademarks, logos, and screenshots referenced remain the property of their respective owners.

Data licensed under CC-BY-NC 4.0